Quick Answers
Can I receive insurance payments from two companies for the same hailstorm?
If you have both homeowner’s insurance and a qualifying standalone hail policy, you may receive separate payments after the same storm.
Does a standalone hail payment reduce my homeowner’s insurance payment?
No. They are separate policies that don’t communicate with each other.
Can I use standalone hail insurance to pay my homeowners deductible?
You can use the cash that you receive from your standalone hail policy claim to use however you desire.
For more information on this topic, see our FAQ section at the bottom of the page.
When a spring hailstorm rolled through McKinney, Jeff knew his roof was taking a beating. What started as a few small hailstones quickly turned into quarter-sized chunks of ice bouncing off his driveway. For nearly twenty minutes, the storm pounded his house before finally moving out of the neighborhood.
The next morning, Jeff walked outside and found pieces of damaged shingles scattered across his yard. He called a roofer, who confirmed what Jeff already suspected. The storm had done enough damage that he needed a new roof. Jeff wasn't thrilled about replacing his roof, but he had homeowners insurance and figured the company would take care of most of the cost.
He called his insurance agent and filed a claim. The adjuster inspected the damage, approved the roof replacement, and issued a payment after subtracting Jeff's wind and hail deductible.
But here's where Jeff's situation gets interesting.
Several months earlier, Jeff had purchased a standalone hail policy to help with that deductible. So while his regular homeowners insurance company was handling the roof replacement claim, Jeff also filed a separate claim with his standalone hail company. That company verified the storm using weather data, reviewed the photos of his damaged roof, and approved a cash payment under its own policy.
One hailstorm. One damaged roof. Two different insurance companies issuing two separate payments.
Jeff could use the money from both policies to help pay for his new roof, including the deductible his regular homeowners insurance left him responsible for. If you've always thought one storm meant one insurance claim, that might sound a little strange. But that's what makes standalone hail insurance different. It works independently from your regular homeowners policy, giving you another source of money when a qualifying storm damages your roof.
Why Would Two Insurance Companies Pay for the Same Storm?
Your regular homeowners insurance and standalone hail insurance are two separate policies issued by two different insurance companies. And while they may both pay for damage caused by the same storm, they work very differently.
Your homeowners insurance protects against a wide range of losses, including fire, theft, certain water damage, wind, hail, and liability claims. When you file a hail claim, the company determines the cost of covered repairs, subtracts your deductible, and applies any other restrictions in your policy.
A standalone hail policy has a much narrower purpose. The standalone hail policy currently available in Texas provides a cash payment when a qualifying wind or hailstorm causes verifiable damage to your home.
Instead of calculating how much it will cost to repair the damage, the standalone insurance company checks weather records to confirm the storm met its requirements. It also reviews photos or other documentation showing that the storm damaged your home. When those conditions are met, the company pays the cash amount you selected when you purchased the policy, subject to its terms.
That's the big difference. Your homeowners insurance pays based on the covered cost of repairs, while your standalone hail policy pays a set cash amount when specific conditions are met. Because the policies operate independently, both companies may issue payments for damage caused by the same storm, giving you another source of money to help cover your repair expenses.
How Do the Two Payments Work Together?
Let's go back to Jeff's situation in McKinney.
His homeowners insurance covered the roof replacement after subtracting his $8,000 wind and hail deductible. Fortunately, Jeff also had a standalone hail policy that provided an $8,000 cash payment because the storm met its requirements.
The two payments came from separate insurance companies, each following its own policy criteria. Jeff could use the standalone payment to help cover the deductible his homeowners insurance left him responsible for. It’s important to understand a specific distinction. The standalone hail policy doesn't eliminate your homeowners insurance deductible. It provides a separate cash payment that you can use to help pay it.
And that payment isn't automatic. The storm must meet the standalone policy's weather requirements and cause verifiable damage to your home. Although unlikely, it's possible for a storm to cause damage covered by your homeowners insurance without qualifying for a standalone hail payment. That's why understanding how both policies work is important.
When both policies respond to the same storm, you can use the cash from your standalone policy to help pay the deductible from your homeowner’s policy.
Do the Two Insurance Companies Communicate With Each Other?
No. Your homeowners insurance and standalone hail insurance are two completely separate policies issued by two different companies. Neither company needs to know what the other is paying to handle its own claim.
Your homeowners insurance company inspects the damage, determines what your policy covers, subtracts your deductible, and calculates its payment.
The standalone hail company works differently. It uses weather data to verify that a qualifying storm occurred and reviews photos showing damage to your home. If the storm and damage meet its requirements, the company pays the cash amount you purchased.
You don't even have to file a homeowners insurance claim to collect from your standalone hail policy. And because the standalone company doesn't report its claims to the CLUE database, filing that claim won't add a loss to your regular homeowners insurance claims history.
At Insurance for Texans, we work for you and not a specific insurance company. Even though the policies come from two different companies, we can sell you both. That means if a hailstorm damages your home, you have one agency to call. We understand how both policies work and can help you navigate the claims process to maximize your benefits.

What Are Benefits of Standalone Hail Coverage?
A large deductible isn't the only reason homeowners might consider standalone hail coverage. Some Texas home insurance companies subtract depreciation from roof claims based on the age and condition of the roof. Others use roof payment schedules that limit how much they'll pay as the roof gets older.
That means a hailstorm could cause $25,000 in roof damage, but your homeowners insurance might pay considerably less after applying depreciation, your deductible, and other restrictions.
A standalone hail policy can provide another source of cash to help cover those expenses. The coverage we offer allows homeowners to select a cash benefit of up to $25,000.
And here's another advantage. You don't have to file a homeowners insurance claim to collect from your standalone hail policy. Let's say Jeff's roof only suffered $6,000 in damage, but his homeowners deductible was $8,000. Filing a claim with his regular insurance company wouldn't result in a payment. However, if the storm meets the standalone policy's requirements, Jeff could receive his selected cash benefit without filing a homeowners claim at all.
Whether you're facing a large deductible, depreciation, or repairs that cost less than your deductible, standalone hail coverage can give you another way to pay for storm damage.
Will a Standalone Hail Policy Pay After Every Storm?
Standalone hail insurance has specific requirements that must be met before a claim is paid out.
The policy currently on the market in Texas requires hail to be approximately the size of a quarter or larger, or winds that reach a specified speed comparable to an EF0 tornado. Those winds can come from a tornado or a straight-line windstorm.
Then, the company uses weather data to confirm the storm meets those requirements. You also need photos or other documentation showing verifiable damage to your home. If both conditions are met, the policy pays the cash benefit you purchased.
Another benefit is that the standalone policy allows up to two qualifying claims per policy year. That's helpful in Texas, where more than one damaging storm can hit the same neighborhood in a single year.
Is Buying Two Insurance Policies Worth It?
Most Texas homeowners aren't looking to buy more insurance. They're looking for better protection without spending more money. Sometimes, buying two separate policies can actually accomplish that.
Think about a homeowner with a $12,000 wind and hail deductible. If a storm damages their roof, that's a significant amount of money to come up with before their homeowners insurance pays anything. A standalone hail policy would provide cash to help cover that expense when a qualifying storm damages their home. It may also help offset depreciation or roof payment restrictions that leave the homeowner responsible for even more of the repair bill.
But here's where the strategy gets interesting.
Increasing the wind and hail deductible on your regular homeowners policy may lower your annual premium. In some cases, those savings can help pay for a standalone hail policy, making the total cost of both policies more affordable than keeping a smaller deductible on your homeowners insurance alone.
We've helped Texas homeowners use this approach to find a better balance between cost and protection.
Of course, the numbers don't work for everyone. Some homeowners already have good roof coverage, manageable deductibles, and enough savings to handle a storm claim. They may not need additional insurance. That's why we help you to look at your total cost of risk. Our goal isn’t to sell you more insurance. It is to spend your money wisely for the best overall financial protection.
True Texas Home Insurance
A Texas hailstorm can cause thousands of dollars in damage in just a few minutes. And the last thing you want is to discover that your deductible and roof coverage restrictions leave you paying more than you expected.
At Insurance For Texans, we believe the best time to solve those problems is before the storm arrives.
Through our True Texas Home Insurance program, we help homeowners find the right balance between premiums, deductibles, and protection. Sometimes that means choosing a traditional homeowners policy with better coverage. Other times, combining it with standalone hail insurance can provide additional protection while keeping the overall cost affordable.
If you're paying more for home insurance while taking on bigger deductibles and less roof coverage, it's time to rethink how you're protecting your home.
Click the button below to start a conversation with our home insurance team.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get more money than the actual cost of my home repairs after a hailstorm?
It is possible. A standalone hail policy is an indemnity policy that pays a specific cash amount that you have purchased in advance. If your payout is more than the cost of your home repairs after a qualifying claim, you keep the rest of the cash to use how you wish.
Do I have to file claims against both my homeowner’s insurance policy and my standalone hail policy?
No. You can file a claim against one or the other policy or both. They are completely separate policies that don’t communicate with each other.
Can a standalone hail policy pay if my homeowners company denies the roof claim?
Possibly. The standalone company evaluates the storm under its own conditions. A homeowners claim denial doesn't automatically determine whether the standalone hail policy will pay.

